The Constitution Unit Blog

Menu

Skip to content
  • Home
  • Brexit
  • Elections and referendums
    • 2017 general election
    • EU referendum
    • 2015 general election
    • AV referendum
    • All
  • Parliament
    • House of Commons
    • House of Lords
    • All
  • Government
    • Cabinet manual
    • Coalition
    • Special advisers
    • All
  • Devolution
    • Scotland
    • Wales
    • Northern Ireland
    • England
    • All
  • Other themes
    • Judiciary and human rights
      • Judicial independence
      • All
    • Parties and politicians
    • Constitutions and constitution making
    • Freedom of information
    • Monarchy, church and state
    • International
    • Events
  • Staff contributors
    • Meg Russell
    • Alan Renwick
    • Robert Hazell
    • Jennifer Hudson
    • Roberta Damiani
    • Rebecca McKee
    • Michela Palese
    • Jess Sargeant
    • Ruxandra Serban
    • Jack Sheldon
    • Honorary staff
      • Daniel Gover
      • Bob Morris
      • Patrick O’Brien
      • Akash Paun
      • Brian Walker
      • Alan Whysall
      • Ben Worthy
      • Ben Yong
  • Constitution Unit website
  • About the Constitution Unit
  • Copyright

Tag Archives: The Will of the People: A Modern Myth

Not So Fast with AV in a Second Referendum

Posted on October 2, 2018 by The Constitution Unit

albert_weale (1)As the debate about whether or not to have a second Brexit referendum continues, the form any such process might take remains unclear. Ahead of the launch of his new book on particpatory democracy, Albert Weale argues that caution should be exercised when considering the use of the Alternative Vote system in any future Brexit referendum. 

In a valuable blog on what question might be put to voters in a second Brexit referendum, Jess Sargeant, Alan Renwick and Meg Russell conclude that if a three-way option is put to voters, the alternative vote (AV) system could be the right one to use. The basis for this conclusion is that when three options are involved, the option that receives the single largest number of votes may not receive an overall majority. So some system is needed to find out if there is an all-round winner, and the AV system of voting will do this.

It is certainly true that when voters have to choose among three alternatives, the operation of majority voting gets quite complex. This is one of the reasons why, as I explain in my forthcoming The Will of the People: A Modern Myth, it is relying on a myth to talk about ‘the will of the people’ emerging from a referendum. This does not mean abandoning majority voting. But it does mean that we need to be careful in the way we apply the majority principle. Continue reading →

Posted in Brexit, Elections and referendums, Public Engagement and Policy Making | Tagged Albert Weale, Alternative Vote, AV, Brexit, Brexit referendum, condorcet cycle, Condorcet winner, no deal, no deal Brexit, overall majority, participatory democracy, People's Vote, remain, second referendum, The Mechanics of a Further Referendum on Brexit, The Will of the People: A Modern Myth | 1 Comment

The Constitution Unit in the Department of Political Science at University College London is the UK's leading research body on constitutional change.

This blog features regular posts from academics and practitioners covering a wide range of constitutional issues in the UK and overseas. You can navigate by theme and contributor using the menus at the top of this page, and subscribe to receive new posts to your inbox below.

Enter your e-mail address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by e-mail.

Join 1,825 other followers

Unit Mailing List: Sign up to receive notifications of of our events, newsletter and publications

Mailing List

Search the blog chronologically

Monitor 70 – Brexit: the uncertain road ahead

The Mechanics of a Further Referendum on Brexit

The Independent Commission on Referendums

Legislation At Westminter

Our senior team

Blog at WordPress.com.
Cancel