Judges and the Media

The Judicial Independence Project recently held its second seminar for professionals (judges, politicians, civil servants and journalists, amongst others) on the topic of ‘Judicial Independence, Judicial Accountability and the Media’.

Perhaps the most noteworthy part of the discussion was a general acceptance by seminar participants that judges are influenced by the media in their judicial behaviour. The effect is particularly evident in sentencing: sentences have increased significantly in the last 20 years. Opinions differed as to whether this influence is a good thing. Some pointed to the success of media campaigns in overturning injustice, for example in challenging flawed expert evidence in the case of Angela Cannings and Sally Clarke. For others, the media was described as ’emotional, irrational and obsessed with the short term’ and their influence was – or could be – damaging. One example cited was of the change in the law of damages to reflect a ‘compensation culture’ that Government research has shown does not exist.

Participants also expressed concern about the recent use of parliamentary privilege to break court orders and about a more general trend of ambivalence about judicial independence in Parliament. The continuing importance of the sub judice rule was emphasised.

The seminar was run under Chatham House Rule, but we have prepared a short anonymised note of the discussion.

One thought on “Judges and the Media

  1. An honest oboiavrtesn there about these forthcoming elections. Once the wretched Lisbon Treaty is fully ratified I see the Irish are likely to give it a yes before the Tories inevitably get into power then the deck will be cleared again for all parties to have a re-think of European policy.We the people of whatever political stripe must then force these charlatans to take account of the singlest and biggest elephant in the room of the British peoples freedom and liberty: all parties must come up with credible policies to take account of this fact rather than the playing for time tactics that the parties are up to at present.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s