The Welsh referendum result: Wales said Yes

The results from the referendum on the National Assembly’s legislative powers on 3 March produced a very clear mandate for the Assembly to have primary law-making powers: the vote is 517,132 votes in favour, and 297,380 votes against (or 63.5 per cent to 36.5 per cent).  There’s news coverage from the BBC here and the official results from the Electoral Commission are here.  Of the local authority areas used for counting, only Monmouthshire voted No – and that by just 320 votes.  While the Yes vote appears to have been weaker in eastern parts of the country, it varied relatively little across the country (and much less than it did in 1997).  There’s a good discussion by Roger Scully of the result on the BBC News website, available here.

Turn out was 35.2 per cent; not high, but higher than in some other referendums, and higher than some predictions.  Given the limited public visibility of the campaign (compounded by True Wales’s decision not to apply to become a designated campaign organisation), the inherent obscurity of the issue and the confusing nature of the question, that has to be regarded as a comparatively strong showing.  Rachel Banner of True Wales has accepted that it’s a clear mandate for an Assembly with legislative powers.  This result suggests strongly that legislative devolution is indeed the settled will of the people of Wales.  Perhaps the shadows created by the defeat in 1979 and narrowest of victories in 1997 will now pass into history.

Ironically, the result comes just as the Boundary Commission for Wales announces how it plans to review the Westminster constituency boundaries, so as to reduce the number of Welsh MPs from 40 to 30 (the same quota as for England or Scotland).  One of the problems that hobbled No campaigners was the prospect of reduced representation at Westminster whatever happened.  If Wales had voted No, it would have faced the double whammy of that combined with limited devolved legislative powers – a sure way to minimise Wales’s overall influence over government.

The referendum result has triggered a flurry of activity on other fronts.  First, there is the question of bringing the new powers into force.  The First Minister announced on Tuesday that an order regarding that would be laid later in the week for debate on 29 March, and providing for the new powers to come into effect on 5 May (polling day in the Assembly elections, of course).   His statement is here.  That means the new Assembly will have primary law-making powers as soon as it meets.  At the same time, work is underway on formalities like letters patent and a Welsh seal for signifying Royal assent to Assembly Acts.

Second, the debate about the Assembly’s finances has revived.  The referendum put this on hold – Welsh politicians didn’t particularly want to talk about it during the campaign, and the UK Government had signalled that it would only take action if there was a Yes vote.  But now confusion reigns.  Some politicians – including Nick Clegg and Cheryl Gillan, both speaking at their parties’ conferences in Cardiff at the weekend – have stuck to the Coalition’s commitment in the Programme for Government about a further commission to look at the issue, despite the work of the Holtham Commission.  Other UK politicians have moved beyond this and talked about implementing Holtham, though with greater interest in tax powers than a ‘fair’ (needs-related) grant.  Carwyn Jones, on the other hand, is keener on a ‘fair grant’ than tax-varying powers.  There’s also the question of whether a further referendum on that would be needed.

All this makes for exciting times in Wales’s developing constitution, in the short interval between the referendum and the start of the Assembly election campaigns.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s